Picture copyright
Shibu Philip

Picture caption

Shibu Philip’s agency has used the software program Hubstaff for the final yr and a half

Shibu Philip admits he is aware of what it is wish to “perhaps waste a little bit of time at work”.

Shibu is the founding father of Transcend – a small London-based agency that buys magnificence merchandise wholesale and re-sells them on-line.

For the final yr and a half he has used Hubstaff software program to trace his staff’ hours, keystrokes, mouse actions and web sites visited.

With seven workers primarily based in India, he says the software program ensures “there may be some degree of accountability” and helps plug the time distinction.

“I do know myself. [You can] take an additional 10-minute break right here or there. It is good to have an automated method of monitoring what [my employees] are as much as,” says Shibu.

“By taking a look at screenshots and the way a lot time everyone seems to be taking over sure duties, I do know in the event that they’re following procedures.

“And, in the event that they’re doing higher than I anticipated, I additionally examine the photographs and ask them to share that data with the remainder of the staff so we are able to all enhance,” he says.

Workers are totally conscious that the software program is in use and may delete time spent visiting web sites that may have been logged accidentally throughout their break, for instance, Shibu provides.

Dwelling ‘shirkers’?

With extra of us than ever working from residence throughout the coronavirus pandemic, there was a spike in demand from employers for surveillance software program.

US-based Hubstaff says its variety of UK prospects is up 4 instances year-on-year since February.

Media playback is unsupported in your machine

Media captionIs your boss spying on you as you work at home?

One other firm referred to as Sneek affords expertise that takes photographs of staff by their laptop computer and uploads them for colleagues to see.

Images will be taken as usually as each minute, though the agency describes itself as a communication platform and says “everybody on the app has the identical expertise whether or not they’re an employer or an worker”.

Its co-founder, Del Currie, advised the BBC that it had seen a five-fold improve in its variety of customers throughout lockdown, taking the agency to nearly 20,000 in whole.

A current examine by teachers at Cardiff College and the College of Southampton discovered {that a} widespread concern amongst bosses is that out-of-sight staff will “shirk”, though lockdown did not really seem to have had a lot of an impact on output both method.

The survey additionally advised {that a} third of residence staff felt that their productiveness had fallen too.

However is expertise the reply to both catch out those that may be slacking off or to assist these struggling to regulate to working from the kitchen desk full-time?

‘I might have felt dangerous if any person was monitoring me’

Picture caption

Photographer Josh says he struggled with each logistics and motivation

Josh, a 26-year-old photographer residing in London, admits that the factor he discovered hardest about working from residence was the drop in his productiveness.

Organising a makeshift studio within the kitchen of his three-bedroom flatshare was logistically difficult however he additionally struggled with motivation.

“Some days I might get by every little thing, however others I might sit and stare at a pair of sandals for some time simply pondering, ‘I am unable to do that.’ It is too straightforward to only go and put the washing on, or make a cup of tea – you discover methods to distract your self fairly simply.”

He’s grateful his boss does not use any monitoring software program on him. “These days when it was a bit tougher to be motivated, I might have felt dangerous if I knew any person was monitoring my productiveness,” he says.

Josh has lengthy suspected that he has consideration deficit hyperactivity dysfunction (ADHD), which might make it troublesome to pay attention and handle his time. His physician agrees, though he is nonetheless on a ready listing for a check.

Having returned to the workplace just lately, he’s valuing having some extra face-to-face interplay. “I discover a routine, construction actually anchoring and it helps me get by all of it.”

Monitoring have to be ‘proportionate’

Whereas some bosses who use a lot of these software program may argue that it is good for sustaining productiveness, analysis by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Growth (CIPD) means that office surveillance can injury belief.

“Monitoring worker behaviour is usually a justifiable solution to scale back the danger of misconduct and doubtlessly assist handle efficiency,” says Jonny Gifford, senior adviser for organisational behaviour analysis on the CIPD.

“Nonetheless, employers ought to have clear insurance policies in order that staff know the way they could be monitored, and crucially, it have to be proportionate.”

Employers will get “a lot better outcomes” by supporting workers, he provides, “relatively than specializing in doubtlessly irrelevant measures of enter, such because the variety of keystrokes”.

Jonathan Rennie, associate at UK regulation agency TLT, additionally urges warning for companies contemplating introducing such software program.

“Employers have an implied authorized responsibility to take care of their workers’ belief and confidence, and should be aware of how workers may react to the mass roll-out of monitoring software program,” he says.

He means that any companies utilizing monitoring software program ought to have written insurance policies in place explaining how and why it’s getting used.

There also needs to be clear steering for managers and safeguards in place to forestall misuse or “over-monitoring”, he says.

Does your employer monitor your productiveness at residence? How would you’re feeling about being monitored? Share your experiences by emailing

Please embrace a contact quantity if you’re prepared to talk to a BBC journalist. You too can get in contact within the following methods:

  • WhatsApp: +44 7756 165803
  • Tweet: @BBC_HaveYourSay
  • Please learn our phrases & situations and privateness coverage

In case you are studying this web page and may’t see the shape you’ll need to go to the cell model of the BBC web site to submit your query or remark or you’ll be able to electronic mail us at


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here